An interesting comparison between both painters and images of the same location.
Pierre-Auguste Renoir, La Grenouillére, 1869, oil on canvas, National Museum, Stockholm
The Impressionists are the artists in France during the 1870s. It all really started with radical leanings among the painters, who came out in open opposition against academic conventionalism in art.
They wanted to get away from the classical insistence on an enclosed pictorial form, a varnished surface. They wanted their painterly technique to be open-ended, and they refused to delimit their subjects in the accepted way. This approach eventually caught on everywhere in western art, and it has left its imprint on the paintings of the 1870s and 1880s.
Auguste Renoir’s La Grenouillère, the frog pond, has all these ingredients - a sketch-like painting, which to contemporaries seemed unfinished, no carved-out details, a glitter of sun reflecting the movements of the water, the boats partly truncated to convey a sense of the passing moment, and the individual details toned down in favour of the overall picture. But, the depiction of reality is still there.
Renoir has depicted an actual moment and life as it is lived, a fragment without any greater depth of interpretation. The theme is a new one: instead of something heroic, we have a casual, trivial excerpt from reality, held together by the lighting.
http://www.nationalmuseum.se/sv/English-startpage/Collections/Painting/19th-century/La-Grenouillere—/
Claude Monet, La Grenouillère, 1869, oil on canvas, Metropolitan Museum of Art, New York,29 3/8 x 39 1/4 in. (74.6 x 99.7 cm), Signed and inscribed: (lower right) Claude Monet; (right) LOCATI[ON] CANOT[S] (boat rental)
Monet noted on September 25, 1869, “I do have a dream, a painting [tableau], the baths of La Grenouillère, for which I have made some bad sketches [pochades], but it is only a dream. Renoir, who has just spent two months here, also wants to do this painting.” Monet and Renoir, both desperately poor, were quite close at this time.
This painting and one in London (National Gallery) are probably the “pochades” Monet mentioned; another painting, now lost but formerly in the Arnhold collection in Berlin, may well have been the “tableau” that he dreamed of. The broad, constructive brushstrokes here are clearly those of a sketch; at this time, Monet sought a more delicate and carefully calibrated surface for his exhibition pictures. (A nearly identical composition by Renoir is in the Nationalmuseum, Stockholm.)
Monet and Renoir both recognized in La Grenouillère—a spa and working-class resort—an ideal subject for the images of leisure they hoped to sell. Optimistically promoted as a “Trouville-sur-Seine,” it was easily accessible by train from Paris and had just been favored with a visit by Emperor Napoleon III and his wife and son.